Home
Up
 

 

    Find out what's happening in Opera - New York City and around the World

OperaNotes Review
 

New Jersey Symphony Orchestra, NJPAC

May 14, 2004
By Charlene Frank

Passion & Consequences
Excerpts from Le Nozze de Figaro

Music: Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart
Conductor: George Manahan


Cast:

Figaro:  Andrew Wentzel
Susanna: Tonna Miller
  Marcellina:  Edith Dowd
Count Almaviva: Stephen Powell
Countess Almaviva:
Cynthia Watters
Cherubino: 
Jennifer Hines
Doctor Bartolo: 
Jason Grant

Don Basilio:  Dean Anthony

 

It would have been enough to hear a symphony with the Golden Age Collection of string instruments that brings the New Jersey Symphony Orchestra into a class of its own.  The orchestra itself still has some growing to do to bring itself up to the class of its instruments, but with this new collection the bar has been raised, so they have nowhere to go but up. 

It would have been enough, but we got more.  We got singers (not to mention the conductor, George Manahan) from the New York City Opera performing a concert of excerpts from Le Nozze de Figaro.  Set in the castle of Count Almaviva near Seville the passion runs high.  Love, lust, hatred, vengeance, conspiracies, and since this is a comic opera, the consequences are that they live happily ever after, exactly the way Passion & Consequences work in real life.  

When I go to an opera or to a concert alone (and when I'm not alone) I often meet the people sitting around me and listen to what they have to say about their experience.  Plus, that's what makes taking public transportation home after the performance so interesting, people are talking about the performance.  So, as I give you my opinion, I also share what I've heard from people who may have much more opera experience than I, and from people who have just had their first exposure to opera.  When I tell them that I'll be writing a review, I never have a lack of input, and I love that, especially from opera virgins. 

Last night there were some overwhelmingly consistent remarks, first an foremost was the youth and beauty of the performers, and the magnificent voices coming from these young people.  People still think of opera as something for the old, rich and gray haired, making sounds that they can't and don't want to understand.  Last night showed quite a few of those people (at least those sitting near me) that they couldn't be more wrong.  They loved it.  I heard the same comments on "The Loop" (a great service the City of Newark has set up to take you from the NJPAC to Newark Penn Station for $1.10).  People had a great time and were thoroughly entertained.  That's really what its all about, isn't it?

This was a concert and more.  In a traditional opera concert, it is about 95% singing and 5% acting.  It is a concert, not an opera.  Last night was more like an opera without costume and set.  There was a lot of acting, a lot of very good acting.  Although there were no surtitles, people understood what was happening because the acting showed them.  One man on the Loop even told me that if Susanna (Tonna Miller) wasn't an opera singer, she could be an actor.

Cynthia Watters (Countess Almaviva ) was a beautiful and interesting soprano who fit the part of a Countess very well,  and was able to grab our hearts with her sadness and humiliation.  The Duettino "Che soave seffiretto" between the Ms. Watters and Ms. Miller was truly a treat. 

I've seen baritone Stephen Powell (Count Almaviva) in a number of roles, and every time I see him I have to force the very impressive picture of Eugene Onegin out of my mind.  It only took a few minutes to do that last night.  He was quite the rich Count, in voice and presence. 

Pairing Edith Dowd (Marcellina) against Tonna Miller was a beautiful contrast of sopranos.  Two beautiful sopranos, the dark and the light, complementing each other with venom.  Very well done.

When Jennifer Hines (Cherubino) entered the stage I was fairly sure of what the reaction would be, because I've seen her perform before, and the reaction is always the same.  How does that strong, deep, mature voice come out of that tiny person?  I always answer the same way " I don't know".  People said the same thing last night, and  I wish I could have a more intelligent answer, but I've been shocked each time I've heard that voice come out of that little body.  She has an amazing instrument. 

A few weeks ago someone said something to me that I haven't been able to forget.  If those who run the operas in our area are concerned about their finances, wouldn't it be wonderful to bring a young, talented group of people like this into the schools throughout our country to show our school children how really wonderful opera can be?  What do children know about opera other than Bugs Bunny running around with horns singing HoHoToHo! If you want to ensure that there is a next generation of opera lovers, show them opera!  Don't make them come to you, because they won't.  Go to them!  We have, without argument, the most important opera house in the world right here in New York City, and we have New York City Opera, and other small houses and venues where opera is available every night of the year, but most people know absolutely nothing about it.  These young and talented performers (they sing and they act) are exactly what is needed to teach our children  that opera isn't something totally weird and as foreign to them as something from another planet.  It is art, beautiful art and entertainment, and often fun.  

I've said my piece.  When you get an opportunity to see these talented artists, please take it.  I will try to ensure that their performances are listed on the Upcoming Events pages on this website.

 

SUPPORT THE ARTS!
Opera News, Opera Reviews, Opera Places and Opera Events - New York and around the World
Copyright OperaNotes. Last updated: January 16, 2005